Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Thomas - The Intellectual Doubter


My small group has been studying the issue of doubt recently, and of course you can’t talk about doubt without talking about Doubting Thomas. Most of the time, this guy gets kind of a bad rep. I remember growing up he was always used as a bad example: “Don’t be a Doubting Thomas!” You’ve probably experienced this too. Which is why I wanted to write this post – let’s give the guy a break, shall we?

First, let’s talk about what kind of guy Thomas was. Do you think he was this surly, pessimistic guy who never thought anything good could happen? We all know the words he’s known for: “Unless I see in his hands the mark of the nails, and place my finger into the mark of the nails, and place my hand into his side, I will never believe.” But remember, this homeboy was chosen by Jesus, aka God on this earth (yes, Judas was too, but that was for a different purpose).

Some lesser-known sayings of Thomas can be found in John 11:16. This is in the middle of the Lazarus story, when Jesus is about to go “awaken” his dead friend. It’s Thomas who leads the other disciples with this appeal: “Let us also go, that we may die with him.”

WHOA. Talk about commitment level to Jesus.

Another time where Thomas shows up is John 14, when Jesus is talking about his imminent departure. In 3-4, he has just said “I go forth to prepare a place for you.” Thomas pipes up in verse 5: “Lord, we do not know where you are going. How can we know the way?” Which of course Jesus answers with “I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life…”

It seems to me that in that particular verse, Thomas merely wanted more information. He was curious about where Jesus was going, and he wanted to go too. He wanted to go so much that he asked for clarification on the directions he’d just been given – something that I do a lot with physical directions, because I am not good at finding my way around. There is nothing wrong with asking for clarification, just like there is nothing wrong for asking to repeat a direction or for a student to ask a teacher for more clear instructions on an assignment. Thomas was an intellectual – he wanted to be absolutely certain that he understood what was going on.

At this point, we are getting closer and closer to Jesus’ death. These disciples have followed him for three years – he has been their central point and their solid home base in their travels. Their lives have rested on him and what he has taught them. Most of them think that he is going to set up a physical, earthly kingdom by overthrowing the Romans, and by association with him they will have important official positions. Their worlds revolve around Jesus.

And then everything goes to hell.

With Jesus crucified, can you imagine the sort of emotions they were feeling? Think of the last time someone let you down – if it was a relationship, when it was ended. When someone you loved suddenly died. When you depended on someone and they failed to come through. It’s a crushing feeling, and we’ve all experienced it. Sometimes we withdraw from other people, sometimes we just lose all hope. It’s hard, a lot of times, to believe that things will get better. So can you really blame Thomas for doubting?

His world had just fallen apart, and then suddenly his friends are running up to him like “Dude! You won’t believe this, but Jesus is back! Totally alive, bro!”

Now, Thomas had seen Jesus bring other people back from the dead. But he’d never brought himself back from the dead before. And if Thomas is anything like me, his first thought was probably “This is too good to be true.” It makes me wonder – was he afraid to get his hopes up in case he was disappointed? Was he afraid to trust again after everything he believed in had just fallen apart? That’s what I see a lot in myself, and I’m sure with other people as well.

Now, the cool thing is, the story doesn’t end there. Jesus could have just been like, “You know what? That Thomas is never going to believe unless I show him something. Too bad for him; he doesn’t have enough faith.” But that totally is not what happens! Instead, Jesus appears to them again, this time with Thomas in the room, and invites Thomas to “Do not disbelieve, but believe.” Jesus went out of his way to grow Thomas’ faith. And once he’d seen Jesus, Thomas had a complete turnaround. He doesn’t touch Jesus, as he said he would to see the nail marks and pierced side. Instead, the first thing he does is worship: “My Lord and my God!”

Struggling with doubt is not a sin – in the same way that we can’t build muscles without straining them, we can’t build our faith without struggle. However, if we attempt to struggle alone when the load gets too heavy – like lifting weights that are too heavy – that’s dangerous. But the next few words Jesus says carry a loaded message: “Blessed are those who have not seen and have yet believed.”

That’s us. We who are believers nowadays have not seen Jesus, but believed in him anyways. Blessed are we who find in Christ the faith to overcome our doubts. God will go a long way in revealing himself to someone who really wants to believe. It shouldn’t have taken Jesus showing up personally to Thomas for Thomas to believe, but Jesus did it anyway. If we truly want to believe, there is nothing God won’t do to show us.



Most biblical quotations taken from the ESV, unless I paraphrased them into the Jeddie Bristow version.

The book we’re going through is called Lord, Change my Attitude by James McDonald and Barb Peil if you would like to check it out for yourself.

No comments:

Post a Comment